Ad Info

Google
 WWW  Mommy Chats
 

Mothering Magazine Sponsored Chat with Rachel Gathercole:
Rachel is the proud mother of three children, ages ten, seven, and five months and the author of numerous articles on parenting and homeschooling, including the Mothering article Homeschooling's True Colors. She is also the author of a forthcoming book on homeschool socialization, to be released early in 2007.

www.mothering.com
6/14/06

20 mamas in attendance

12:06:04 Webmama_Tina ok today we have rachel gathercole as our guest speaker! rachel, why don't you introduce yourself and tell us a little about your background and expertise and such...don't forget to promote any websites or books you might have! :)
12:06:12 Webmama_Tina and let me know when you are ready to take your first question
12:06:19 Rachel_Gathercole Okay, thanks!
12:06:28 Webmama_Tina and mamas...you can start throwing out your question marks to get in line for talking to rachel. :)
12:06:36 Webmama_Tina i expect we'll get more people in here soon
12:08:01 avocado123 hello
12:08:14 Webmama_Tina hi  avocado123 , glad you made it! we're just getting started1
12:08:18 Webmama_Tina Welcome to this week's Mothering Sponsored chat! This is a moderated chat. Please make sure you read and fully understand the Moderated Chat Instructions before participating in this chat. Instructions can be found here: http://www.mommychats.com/modrules.htm ...A Friendly Reminder: Please do not post unless it is your turn to ask a question. If you have a question, please post a single ?" and you'll be added to the queue. Have your question ready when your name is called."
12:09:24 avocado123 ?
12:09:44 Rachel_Gathercole Sorry, bear with me, please.  I'm having a little technical problem.  Will only take a second.
12:09:52 Webmama_Tina no worries :)
12:09:56 Webmama_Tina i can certainly relate
12:09:57 Webmama_Tina :)
12:11:02 Rachel_Gathercole I am the mother of three wonderful children who have never been to school, I have been homeschooling for 10 years, and am the author of a number of articles on homeschooling, parenting, and children, including the Mothering article Homeschooling's True Colors.""
12:11:24 kitkatsmama am i here?
12:11:29 Webmama_Tina yes you are!
12:11:31 Rachel_Gathercole I am also the author of a forthcoming book on homeschool socialization, to be released early in 2007.
12:11:46 Rachel_Gathercole I grew up in great public schools, loved school, went on to attend and graduate from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, and am now very happy to be homeschooling my kids.
12:11:53 kitkatsmama whoo hoo- i was poting my questions in the wrong room (oops!)
12:12:12 Webmama_Tina welcome kitkatsmama !
12:12:15 Webmama_Tina Welcome to this week's Mothering Sponsored chat! This is a moderated chat. Please make sure you read and fully understand the Moderated Chat Instructions before participating in this chat. Instructions can be found here: http://www.mommychats.com/modrules.htm ...A Friendly Reminder: Please do not post unless it is your turn to ask a question. If you have a question, please post a single ?" and you'll be added to the queue. Have your question ready when your name is called."
12:12:21 Rachel_Gathercole When my first child was born I had never even heard of homeschooling.  Everything I know about homeschooling I have learned “on the job” and through research and extensive interviewing I have done since having children.
12:12:27 kitkatsmama thanks.
12:12:28 kitkatsmama ?
12:13:05 Rachel_Gathercole Looking forward to chatting with you all!  Ready for questions.  :)
12:13:08 Webmama_Tina upcoming chatters:  avocado123,  kitkatsmama
12:13:13 Webmama_Tina you're up first avocado!
12:13:25 avocado123 i've read john holt. my husband and his bro were homeschooled for several years. it made a huge impact, i believe, in so many ways, all positive and lifelong.
12:13:37 Rachel_Gathercole Glad to hear it.
12:13:40 avocado123 i'm not enamored of the local schools, crowding, violence, worksheets, lugging texts, so many kids so little ability to tailor the program to each kid's pace and abilities, etc. so i want to homeschool (our kids are now 3.5 and 1.5) BUT
12:14:19 avocado123 i don't believe all the socialization arguments i've read on homeschooling sources because i've met several groups of homeschoolers in several different cities. in all cases, the kids did not have the social skills their schooled peers did. and
12:14:39 avocado123 in many cases, they were kids who impressed me as being under their age level in maturity and social interaction skills, as well as some were plain unpleasant. and i love kids. growing up,
12:15:50 avocado123 i was the teen who wante dto work with the tougher kids and always found the diamond in the rough
12:16:05 avocado123 but these homeschooled kids i've met have really done the opposite, they were the kind of kids i didn't see as role models for our kids and i didn't want our kids hanging out with them
12:16:08 mascontay3 hello all
12:16:12 Rachel_Gathercole Are there specific social skills you are referring to that you saw them as lacking?
12:16:31 Webmama_Tina hi  mascontay3 ! glad you could make it!
12:16:32 avocado123 well, communication
12:16:36 Webmama_Tina Welcome to this week's Mothering Sponsored chat! This is a moderated chat. Please make sure you read and fully understand the Moderated Chat Instructions before participating in this chat. Instructions can be found here: http://www.mommychats.com/modrules.htm ...A Friendly Reminder: Please do not post unless it is your turn to ask a question. If you have a question, please post a single ?" and you'll be added to the queue. Have your question ready when your name is called."
12:16:51 avocado123 their learning skills were subpar (i was invited to an intercultural day) and they presented what they learned
12:17:06 avocado123 also the way they interacted amongst themselves wasn't heartening
12:17:10 Rachel_Gathercole Hmm.  Well, I am sorry to hear that that is your experience with homeschooled kids.  I can understand your concern then regarding possibly homeschooling your own kids.
12:17:47 Rachel_Gathercole In general, research seems to indicate, and my experience would agree, that homeschoolers do well socially, and
12:18:19 avocado123 at nursery school our son now spends hours socializing with other kids. he comes home and has just me and a sibling. don't get out much and i'm pregnant with our third and expect to be nesting for a good while longer.
12:18:51 Rachel_Gathercole I wonder why your experience seems not to match that.  Of course,
12:19:07 avocado123 i;ve met homeschoolers in four different cities
12:19:17 avocado123 there is only one left that i haven't checked out 1.5 hours away
12:19:24 avocado123 but how could that possibly be our main socializing?
12:19:47 avocado123 at nursery school there is daily interaction with the same kids....but if we rely on h omeschoolers who don't live in our city it's hard to build on those relationships
12:19:48 Rachel_Gathercole Well, I can suggest a couple things.
12:20:28 Mrs.Peanut Do your children play with the 'schooled' children who live on your street?  That is socializing, too.
12:21:30 avocado123 it is to a certain extent but our neighbors kids have social get togethers for famlies in the school and the kids walk home together and study together
12:22:02 avocado123 trying to nab other kids and their busy lives is tough cuz they go to activities and it's like intruding on their schedules
12:22:04 Rachel_Gathercole One thing is that every family is different and your goals for your children's social experience may not match those of the types of groups you have been to.  There are different types of groups, and some are easier to find than others; I am just speculating that this could be one part of the situation.  One possibility. . .
12:22:24 avocado123 Rachel, i agree with that....but the women were soooo nice!
12:22:29 avocado123 i was just appalled by their kids
12:22:41 Rachel_Gathercole would be for you to start a group for like-minded people, because if you are having a hard time finding a group that matches your needs, then I'm sure others in the area are as well.
12:23:00 avocado123 i don't know of homeschoolers in our city of 70,000
12:23:21 avocado123 that's why i want to fit into a group that meets in another city and draws on folks from all around
12:23:44 avocado123 one group basically told us to go away until our kids were school age cuz they want peers for their kids. that is the closest one to us
12:24:02 avocado123 again, how does that count as socialization, if it's just once every other week? it's far from daily relationships
12:24:18 Rachel_Gathercole There are probably others out there, and they don't know about you, either.  :)  Ultimately, you have to do what's right for your family.
12:24:20 avocado123 i don't mean to monopolize this....i just have these thoughts churninga round for so long and noone to sound them off
12:24:47 Rachel_Gathercole I understand.  Maybe more ideas will come out later.  Good luck with this!
12:24:56 MommaCrystal ?
12:25:17 Rachel_Gathercole Next question?
12:25:34 kitkatsmama can you recommend a good refernce book for getting started?  katherine will be four, and attended preschool two mornings a week this past year- she had a WONDERFUL teacher who could see her potential, but was somewhat bound by the curriculum.
12:26:12 kitkatsmama so, k was a bit bored by the end of the year.  i'm looking for a loose reference guide to point me in the right direction
12:26:31 Webmama_Tina upcoming chatters:  MommaCrystal (after  kitkatsmama )
12:26:41 Rachel_Gathercole Well, the right direction" depends on what you have in mind in terms of what approach you would like to take. . ."
12:27:04 kitkatsmama i think we do some things now that are helpful- cooking, looking for letter recognition in signs, and then seeing how many words we can think of that begin with that letter
12:27:18 Rachel_Gathercole There are many different ways of homeschooling.
12:27:53 Rachel_Gathercole There is a book called Take A Deep Breath. . .You Can Do This!" which you might find helpful."
12:28:12 kitkatsmama well, that's just it, i need to know what the approaches are, first...  i've heard of 'unschooling', but haven't looked much into what it actually is- i just know that for the $1800 preschool would cost next fall, she could be doing so many more things
12:28:36 kitkatsmama (please excuse my awful typing, i'm typing over a sleeping babe)
12:29:17 Rachel_Gathercole That leap" into homeschooling is often the hardest part.  I also would recommend any book by John Holt; "What Do I Do Monday?"  "How Children Learn" etc.  Any of these will give you ideas and help you get started, I think."
12:29:29 Rachel_Gathercole Hope that helps.  Next question?
12:29:36 Rachel_Gathercole I
12:29:39 Webmama_Tina MommaCrystal, you're up
12:29:42 MommaCrystal I would like to hear about specific peer reviewed research articles that discuss the social skills of children who are home schooled.
12:29:58 Rachel_Gathercole Good question!
12:30:16 MommaCrystal Or really any resources.  And who is the author of the Take A Deep Breath book
12:30:42 MommaCrystal Other books.  Plus when will yours be available?  :)
12:31:12 Rachel_Gathercole There have been a number of studies, and whether they are all peer-reviewed I unfortunately cannot say at the moment (though I agree that is important). . .
12:31:18 kitkatsmama thank you for the resources
12:31:31 Rachel_Gathercole You're welcome!
12:33:26 Webmama_Tina avocado123 i'm PM'ing you
12:34:28 Rachel_Gathercole There have been studies of the self-esteem of children in different schooling environments, studies of amounts of problem behavior," self-concept, etc.  Some of these have been in the form of dissertations, etc., and others have been articles.  It would be difficult for me to cite titles, authors, etc., here (though I do go into them in more detail in my book).  You can also look in the book "But What About Socialization?  A Review of the Literature" which sums up lots of studies."
12:35:02 Rachel_Gathercole I'm sorry, I can't remember who the author of that book is, but the publisher is Mapletree Publishing Company.
12:35:18 Rachel_Gathercole My book will be released probably early in 2007.  Thanks for asking! :)
12:35:21 Rachel_Gathercole Next question?
12:35:43 Webmama_Tina no one else in queue....mamas?
12:35:45 MommaCrystal Thank you that was helpful.
12:35:58 MommaCrystal ?
12:36:18 Webmama_Tina i have that book....take a deep breath...
12:36:24 Webmama_Tina i'll go look up the author
12:36:30 Rachel_Gathercole To avocado 123 I have another thought. . .
12:36:38 avocado123 okay
12:37:01 Webmama_Tina go ahead with your question mommacrystal
12:37:21 Webmama_Tina ok the book is homeschooling: take a deep breath--you can do this"  by terri lynn bittner"
12:37:24 Webmama_Tina excellent book!
12:37:47 MommaCrystal Since we have the chance to chat... can you talk about the kinds of social experiences you gave your children?
12:37:58 MommaCrystal What worked, what didn't?  Did you tap into public school?
12:38:22 MommaCrystal How much is too much... or too little, at least as your experience went or those you know.
12:38:30 Rachel_Gathercole In my experience when parents are particularly concerned about one issue, such as their kids having peer contact, these are usually the very parents who are going to make sure that that need is met.  Thus, ironically, it is these parents who have the least need to worry.  Does that make sense?
12:38:46 Rachel_Gathercole Or their kids having a particular quality of peer contact.
12:39:02 Rachel_Gathercole Interesting question, MommyCrystal.
12:39:38 Rachel_Gathercole I have found overwhelmingly that the most important social experiences occur at home.  This I believe is true no matter where your kids are schooled. . .
12:40:04 avocado123 at home with the parent and siblings?
12:41:10 Rachel_Gathercole My children have participated in a large homeschool group all along, and have lots of peer contact, but it is the talking we do at home, and learning skills for living and getting along as a family (yes, parents and sibling) that seem most important.
12:41:37 Rachel_Gathercole These skills carry over to their interactions with their friends.
12:42:35 Rachel_Gathercole I have found a balance of family time (much more than what is possible while attending school) to peer time very helpful.
12:44:17 Rachel_Gathercole I have heard many parents comment that when their kids get up in the morning, they will often ask, Can we play with so-and-so today?" and almost never "Can we play with lots and lots of kids today?"  Many kids seem happiest playing with a few close friends."
12:44:36 Rachel_Gathercole Are there any other questions?
12:44:58 Mrs.Peanut ?
12:45:13 Webmama_Tina go for it mrs peanut
12:46:29 Mrs.Peanut My eldest two children are in school.  I am homeschooling my 5 y-o, my 3 y-o (and our soon-to-be-born).  My husband is not 100% behind the decision to homeschool.  He would prefer the kids to be in private school.  Any suggestions to help convince him?
12:46:43 Rachel_Gathercole What are his concerns?
12:47:07 Mrs.Peanut Well, he's not very clear about that.  Of course, he has mentioned socialization as an issue.
12:47:29 Rachel_Gathercole Naturally.  :)  That is usually everyone
12:47:34 Rachel_Gathercole 's first concern.
12:48:41 Rachel_Gathercole Well, I think that in general people are worried that homeschooled kids won't have peer contact.  But in general, they do. . .
12:49:07 Mrs.Peanut I firmly believe that sending our free-spirited 5 yo to school will destroy her spirit and completely UNsocialize her
12:49:47 Rachel_Gathercole In fact, in interviewing homeschoolers across the country, I was intrigued to discover that the majority of the kids said they have more time to hang out with friends than they did when they were in school.
12:50:19 Rachel_Gathercole They often said that in school, although there were many kids around, they were not really allowed to socialize with them.
12:50:37 Rachel_Gathercole (In the sense that they were not supposed to talk, only had 4 minutes between classes, etc.)
12:51:02 Rachel_Gathercole Why do you feel that sending her to school will destroy her spirit and unsocialize her?
12:51:10 Mrs.Peanut I believe that completely.  Danielle (the 5 yo) goes to Sparks (Girl Guides), we get together weekly with a local pre-homeschool group.
12:51:54 Mrs.Peanut My experience with schooling our eldest two children have shown me that when you put 300+ children in a playground with one adult supervising, children are cruel to each other.
12:52:30 Rachel_Gathercole Homeschoolers often find that, because homeschooling is so efficient (no busywork, attendance, etc.), they have gobs of time to go over to friends' houses, play with groups of kids at the park, etc.
12:52:37 Mrs.Peanut One teacher in a class of 30+ students cannot allow each child to grow and blossom individually - the classroom would be chaotic
12:52:52 Mrs.Peanut Exactly.
12:53:04 Rachel_Gathercole Perhaps if your husband agreed to try it for a year, he would see a difference himself?
12:53:14 avocado123 ?
12:53:24 Rachel_Gathercole Are there any other questions waiting?
12:53:36 Webmama_Tina just avocado123
12:53:51 Rachel_Gathercole Okay, next question, then? :)
12:53:53 avocado123 you mentioned hsers having time to play with other friends.....where do they make these close friends?
12:53:54 drdawn ?
12:54:02 Rachel_Gathercole Excellent question.
12:54:46 Rachel_Gathercole Homeschoolers make friends in many of the same ways school kids do.  Scouts, church/synagogue/etc., soccer, dance class, in the neighborhood, etc., in addition to
12:55:14 Rachel_Gathercole having all day to socialize with other homeschoolers if the family chooses to.  hey find these homeschoolers
12:56:13 Webmama_Tina mommy groups too
12:56:41 Rachel_Gathercole by searching out homeschool groups, which can take patience :), by forming their own groups, etc.  You can also post notices that you are looking for like-minded homeschool friends at community centers, health-food stores, etc.
12:56:44 avocado123 it just seems like we'd have to drive those relationships and actually drive all over town or to other cities. from nursery school, sometimes other moms just call me and invite him over. that seems more natural than having to orchestrate it thorugh activit
12:56:51 avocado123 or force ourselves onto others
12:57:22 avocado123 i wrote down everything you said and will try it
12:57:31 Rachel_Gathercole Also, sometimes community businesses have homeschool events or sessions (like the bowling alley, library, etc.) and you can go to those to hook up with people.  Yes, mommy groups, breastfeeding groups.  You have to look, but they're out there. :)
12:58:00 Mrs.Peanut My eldest daughter is in school and I have to drive all over the city picking her up at friend's homes.  That's life as a mom, homeschooling or not
12:58:33 Rachel_Gathercole Well, I agree.  And hopefully, if you take the time to find the people, then the natural calling and inviting over part gets really easy.  :)
12:58:51 Webmama_Tina also start a yahoogroup
12:58:59 Rachel_Gathercole Good idea!
12:59:21 Webmama_Tina if you build it, they will come""
12:59:34 Rachel_Gathercole Another thing I heard often from homeschoolers I interviewed for my book was that they don't have as many friends, but their friendships are deeper and more rewarding.  This came from kids and parents.
12:59:46 Rachel_Gathercole Any other questions?
12:59:54 Webmama_Tina i think our time is uop
12:59:56 Webmama_Tina up
13:00:21 avocado123 Thank you!
13:00:21 Rachel_Gathercole I wish I could make so many more suggestions.  It's hard in such a short time.
13:00:26 Mrs.Peanut Thank you Tina, Thank you Rachel!
13:00:27 Rachel_Gathercole Thank you!
13:00:33 Webmama_Tina we'll have to have you come back again rachel!
13:00:37 Rachel_Gathercole I would love it.
13:00:44 MommaCrystal Thank you!  I'd love to chat with you again!  SOON!
13:00:47 Webmama_Tina also, anyone that is interested, we have a casual homeschooling chat every sunday evening
13:00:55 Mrs.Peanut what time?
13:00:57 Webmama_Tina there are lots of mamas that might be able to help with more ideas
13:01:19 Webmama_Tina and join your local homeschool organization online, if you have one...
13:01:56 Webmama_Tina yes! maybe you'd like to do a regular homeschool chat? we only have a casual one right now
13:02:04 Webmama_Tina scroll down to the bottom of this page to see the chat calendar
13:02:17 Rachel_Gathercole Keep asking around.  I think you'll find other people who want the same things as you do.  They may have been turned off by the same things you were turned off by, avocado123, and may be looking for you!
13:02:25 Webmama_Tina hs chat is 7/8/9/10p pst/cst/mst/est
13:02:27 Webmama_Tina on sunday
13:02:29 Webmama_Tina s
13:02:49 Webmama_Tina yes, avocadomom, you just need to keep looking....you still have lots of time, your little ones are still very young
13:03:01 Rachel_Gathercole Oh, one more thought. . .
13:03:27 avocado123 gotta decide by next Jan/Feb, just when our third child is born, whether or not to enroll our son in the city kindergarten
13:03:31 jjuulliieett I am living proof of if you built it they will come, but it took 3 years.  Don't give up hope.
13:03:37 Rachel_Gathercole Go to parks, etc., during school hours!  If kids are there, they may be homeschoolers!
13:03:45 avocado123 you built a homeschool group in your city?
13:03:48 jjuulliieett Yes.
13:04:00 jjuulliieett SSSSSSSSLLLLLLLLOOOOOOOOOWWWWWWWWWWLLLLLLLLLLLLYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
13:04:05 Webmama_Tina i did too
13:04:13 avocado123 parks during school hours are so depressing even the babies are taken care of by people other than their parents
13:04:14 Webmama_Tina start with a yahoogroup and a webpage
13:04:15 jjuulliieett but connecting with my midwife for reaching out was great
13:04:24 avocado123 i've got a midwife!
13:04:26 Webmama_Tina where are you avocado?
13:04:40 avocado123 i'm an american living on the other side of the globe.
13:04:44 jjuulliieett many homebirth mamas homeschool
13:04:51 Rachel_Gathercole Also, you can always try it for a while and see how it goes.  The city kindergarten will no doubt take your child in the middle of the year, or the following year, or whatever.  Don't feel pressured.  Do whatever feels right to you.
13:04:54 avocado123 i've been to homeschool groups for english speakers and for nonenglish speakers
13:04:54 jjuulliieett that is where I formed LOTS of connectoins
13:05:26 avocado123 the city kindergarten is competitive, in the sense i want the closest one and they might not want me.
13:05:34 avocado123 so jullie your connections were from your midwife?
13:05:35 Webmama_Tina time for me to go...my dd's yoga class is starting
13:05:37 jjuulliieett Yes, Rachel, I agree.  the pressure is the worst.  Remember that in KG they are still so little, and one year out of school can make such a difference
13:05:40 avocado123 other folks she birthed?
13:05:41 Webmama_Tina y'all stay and chat as long as you like
13:05:49 Webmama_Tina i'll be back to close the room later
13:05:51 Rachel_Gathercole Is there a La Leche League group in the area?  You may find homeschoolers there.
13:05:53 Webmama_Tina THANK YOU RACHEL!!!!
13:05:56 jjuulliieett Yes, avocado, met lots there
13:06:02 Webmama_Tina y'all can casually chat as long as you like...see ya!
13:06:03 jjuulliieett THANK YOU RACHEL
13:06:08 jjuulliieett bye tina
13:06:08 Rachel_Gathercole Thank you so much for having me!
13:06:17 Rachel_Gathercole Bye, Tina!

 

 

Web Template by Jen at Four Little Ducks